Diagnosis and differential diagnosis

Back To Life! A Personal Grief Guidebook

Personal Guidebook to Grief Recovery

Get Instant Access

The main diagnostic challenges are to identify pathological grief, and to identify other mental disorders provoked by bereavement ( Table..?).

Rumke Differential Table Updated

Table 2 Complications of bereavement

Pathological grief has different meanings. It can be defined as follows:(25)

• chronic grief—the failure to resolve all adverse bereavement-related symptoms within 6 months

• inhibited grief—the absence of expected grief symptoms

• delayed grief—the avoidance of painful symptoms within the first 2 weeks of a loss.

An unusually intense bereavement reaction is sometimes described as hypertrophic grief. There is some evidence to suggest that this form of grief may predispose to psychiatric comorbidity.

An alternative way of defining pathological grief is to consider whether it is associated with significant functional disturbance, and secondly to consider whether it is unduly persistent. These two interact. Thus, severely distressing or disabling symptoms at 2 months, moderate symptoms at 6 months, or mild symptoms at 12 months could all reasonably justify a diagnosis of pathological grief.

Depressive disorders are commonly provoked by bereavement, but depressive symptoms are also a part of the normal grieving process. Symptoms tend to occur most frequently within the first 4 months and decline rapidly with time. The proportion of people who continue to satisfy the criteria for a depressive episode declines with time.

DSM-IV offers some guidelines on distinguishing normal grief from depression. The following features are rare in bereavement but common in major depression:

• guilt, except at the time of death

• thoughts of death, except in relation to the deceased

• worthlessness

• psychomotor retardation

• prolonged functional impairment

• hallucinations, except in relation to the deceased.

Another approach is to consider the psychology of the bereaved person. Cognitive distortions involving self, world, and future (Beck's triad) are suggestive of depression, whereas periodic preoccupations are a core feature of grief.

Although less studied than depression, anxiety disorders may also occur after bereavement. The possibility of post-traumatic stress disorder following bereavement should be considered, especially when a death is sudden, unexpected, or violent.

Was this article helpful?

0 0
Natural Depression Cures

Natural Depression Cures

Are You Depressed? Heard the horror stories about anti-depressants and how they can just make things worse? Are you sick of being over medicated, glazed over and too fat from taking too many happy pills? Do you hate the dry mouth, the mania and mood swings and sleep disturbances that can come with taking a prescribed mood elevator?

Get My Free Ebook


Post a comment